Updated Outfielder Rankings (May) - 2018 Fantasy Baseball

7 years ago by Matt Williams

Link copied to clipboard!

TESTING NEW WIDGET hide

We have made it to the end of May in fantasy baseball. Now is the time everyone starts to take a hard look at their roster to make improvements and changes. At Rotoballer we are going to help you out by reshuffling the deck and updating the outfield rankings as a tool in reshaping your squad.

There have been several standouts in the early going who have made a steep climb up the rankings, as well as those who have had a similar fall. Rookies, injuries, and bounce backs have changed the preseason rankings in many ways. I am here to show you who the risers and fallers are, and why. These rankings were made before recent rookies (such as Austin Meadows and Juan Soto) were called up to the majors, so please keep that in mind as you peruse the article. Notes about injuries and missing prospects can be found in the player notes. You can find player analysis for each tier following the rankings chart, That being said, read on! * Rankings/Tiers made by Pierre Camus while Player Analysis was written by Matt Williams.

Don't forget to bookmark our famous Rankings Wizard where you can see all of our rankings for mixed leagues, points leagues, AL/NL only leagues, dynasty leagues, top 2018 prospects, dynasty prospects and more. You will also find our tiers, auction values, player news, stats, projections and more. You can easily download everything - oh, and in case you’re curious, it's all free!

Featured Promo: Want a free RotoBaller Premium Pass? Check out these sports betting promo offers from the top sportsbooks! All new sign-ups get a free bonus offer on their first deposit, and a free year of RotoBaller's Premium Pass for all sports ($450 value)! Sign Up Now!

2018 Fantasy Baseball Tiered Rankings: Outfield (May)

Staff rankings/tiers by Bill Dubiel, Nick Mariano, Pierre Camus while player analysis was written by Matt Williams

Ranking	Tier	Player	Position
1	1	Mike Trout	OF
2	1	Mookie Betts	OF
3	1	Bryce Harper	OF
4	1	Charlie Blackmon	OF
5	1	Aaron Judge	OF
6	1	J.D. Martinez	OF
7	2	Kris Bryant	3B/OF
8	2	Giancarlo Stanton	OF
9	2	Starling Marte	OF
10	2	George Springer	OF
11	3	Cody Bellinger	1B/OF
12	3	Dee Gordon	2B/OF
13	3	Justin Upton	OF
14	3	Tommy Pham	OF
15	3	Rhys Hoskins	1B/OF
16	3	Khris Davis	OF
17	3	Nelson Cruz	OF
18	3	Christian Yelich	OF
19	3	Lorenzo Cain	OF
20	4	Andrew Benintendi	OF
21	4	Marcell Ozuna	OF
22	4	Yoenis Cespedes	OF
23	4	Ronald Acuna	OF
24	4	Mitch Haniger	OF
25	4	Ender Inciarte	OF
26	4	Nick Castellanos	3B/OF
27	4	Andrew McCutchen	OF
28	4	Shohei Ohtani	SP/OF
29	5	Ryan Braun	OF
30	5	Michael Brantley	OF
31	5	Whit Merrifield	2B/OF
32	5	Eddie Rosario	OF
33	5	A.J. Pollock	OF
34	5	Joey Gallo	3B/1B/OF
35	6	Nomar Mazara	OF
36	6	Nick Markakis	OF
37	6	Adam Jones	OF
38	6	Gregory Polanco	OF
39	6	Matt Olson	OF/1B
40	6	Corey Dickerson	OF
41	6	Jose Martinez	OF/1B
42	6	Odubel Herrera	OF
43	6	Michael Conforto	OF
44	6	Yasiel Puig	OF
45	6	Byron Buxton	OF
46	6	Brett Gardner	OF
47	6	Billy Hamilton	OF
48	6	David Peralta	OF
49	6	Delino DeShields	OF
50	6	Chris Taylor	2B/SS/OF
51	6	Kyle Schwarber	OF
52	7	Jay Bruce	OF/1B
53	7	Brandon Belt	1B/OF
54	7	Trey Mancini	1B/OF
55	7	Shin-Soo Choo	OF
56	7	Adam Duvall	OF
57	7	Matt Kemp	OF
58	7	Domingo Santana	OF
59	8	Scooter Gennett	2B/3B/OF
60	8	Jorge Soler	OF
61	8	Kevin Pillar	OF
62	8	Stephen Piscotty	OF
63	8	Max Kepler	OF
64	8	Adam Eaton	OF
65	8	Steven Souza	OF
66	8	Mallex Smith	OF
67	9	Ian Happ	2B/OF
68	9	Teoscar Hernandez	OF
69	9	David Dahl	OF
70	9	Dexter Fowler	OF
71	9	Avisail Garcia	OF
72	9	Franchy Cordero	OF
73	9	Josh Reddick	OF
74	9	Manuel Margot	OF
75	9	Eric Thames	1B/OF
76	9	Ian Desmond	OF/1B
77	10	Aaron Hicks	OF
78	10	Michael Taylor	OF
79	10	Leonys Martin	OF
80	10	Carlos Gonzalez	OF
81	10	Bradley Zimmer	OF
82	10	Travis Jankowski	OF
83	10	Jason Kipnis	2B/OF
84	10	Scott Schebler	OF
85	10	Lewis Brinson	OF
86	10	Dustin Fowler	OF
87	10	Aaron Altherr	OF
88	11	Brandon Drury	3B/OF
89	11	Randal Grichuk	OF
90	11	Jose Pirela	OF/2B
91	11	Mark Trumbo	OF
92	11	Marwin Gonzalez	1B/2B/3B/SS/OF
93	11	Denard Span	OF
94	11	Jackie Bradley	OF
95	11	Mac Williamson	OF
96	11	Jesse Winker	OF
97	11	Howie Kendrick	2B/OF
98	11	Carlos Gomez	OF
99	11	Ben Zobrist	2B/OF
100	11	Kevin Kiermaier	OF
101	12	Derek Fisher	OF
102	12	Chad Pinder	SS/2B/OF
103	12	Chris Owings	2B/SS/OF
104	12	Curtis Granderson	OF
105	12	Eduardo Nunez	SS/3B/2B/OF
106	12	Jose Bautista	OF
107	12	Kole Calhoun	OF
108	12	Joc Pederson	OF
109	12	Kyle Tucker	OF
110	12	Alex Gordon	OF
111	12	Nick Williams	OF
112	12	Cameron Maybin	OF
113	12	Hunter Pence	OF
114	12	Hunter Renfroe	OF
115	12	Harrison Bader	OF
116	12	Jarrod Dyson	OF
117	12	Gerardo Parra	OF
118	13	Clint Frazier	OF
119	13	Raimel Tapia	OF
120	13	Jason Heyward	OF
121	13	Mikie Mahtook	OF
122	13	Albert Almora	OF
123	13	Austin Hays	OF
124	13	Brandon Nimmo	OF
125	13	Andrew Toles	OF
126	13	Preston Tucker	OF
127	13	Ben Gamel	OF
128	13	Alex Verdugo	OF
129	13	Brian Goodwin	OF
130	13	Jon Jay	OF
131	13	Steve Pearce	1B/2B/OF
132	13	Lonnie Chisenhall	OF
133	13	Jorge Bonifacio	OF
134	13	Eloy Jimenez	OF
135	13	Tyler Naquin	OF
136	13	Enrique Hernandez	OF
137	13	Austin Jackson	OF
138	13	Nicky Delmonico	OF
139	13	Matt Joyce	OF
140	13	Melky Cabrera	OF

Tier 1

Mike Trout and Mookie Betts are technically in Tier 1-A, as they are in a class by themselves. Trout is up to his usual tricks in 2018, batting .303/.448/.672 with 18 home runs and 12 stolen bases. The Angels superstar currently has a career high 20.2% BB rate, while maintaining a ridiculous .462 wOBA. The man is amazing and will occupy the top spot in all of fantasy baseball for the foreseeable future.

Mookie Betts owners may have something to say about that though. The Red Sox' center fielder is having a breakout after a breakout in 2018, doing his best Mike Trout impersonation. Betts is carrying his own impressive slash line of .359/.437.750 with 17 home runs and 13 stolen bases this season and has been the fantasy MVP so far. Still, it was not enough to dethrone Trout for the top spot in the outfield. That will take a bit more of a track record by Betts, and also a bit of a decline from Trout himself.

The rest of tier is rounded out by mainstays Charlie Blackmon and soon to be free agent Bryce Harper. Nothing special to report here, they are both great players and are locked into Tier 1-B.

Tier 2

The second the tier is filled with all of the slugging outfielders that can't quite produce enough in all five categories to move into the top tier. Players like Aaron Judge, Kris Bryant, J.D. Martinez, and Giancarlo Stanton settle in to this "next best thing" tier. They are all performing the way we expected, to a degree, and should remain locked in this tier for the season.

The surprise of the tier is our first big "climber" so far in the rankings, Starling Marte. The five-tool stud from the Pirates has been working his reputation back from the stigma of a PED suspension last year, and Marte has not disappointed. The Pittsburgh outfielder is hitting .309/.361/.514 with seven home runs and 10 stolen bases. Marte. like Trout, is earning the highest walk rate of his career and is shaping up to be one of the best early round value of fantasy drafts.

Tier 3

Tier three is a group filled with a power hitter, a speed threat, and a power/speed hybrid. Headlining the group is Astros' star George Springer, followed by Cody Bellinger and Dee Gordon. The Houston outfielder may be the last true "five-category player" with the talent to hit into the top-10 in fantasy drafts. Springer is just not stealing enough anymore to make that a reality. He has still collected three stolen bases to go with 11 home runs and .284 batting average so far. If Springer can bring his walk rate back to his career norm he should be able to climb back up into tier two.

Cody Bellinger has been a bit of a disappointment in 2018. The reigning NL Rookie of the Year is batting just .235/.307/.431 with eight home runs and a 102 wRC+. Fantasy owners are worried about the slugging first baseman, and with his below waiver wire performance it's easy to see why. While he is carrying a career low .278 BABIP, it is hardly enough reason to suspect it will impact a turnaround of noticeable measure. Bellinger's hard contact rate in down 6%, while his ground ball rate is up 7% so far this season. Gains in his chase rate and erased by a small spike in his swinging strike rate. The kid has all of the talent in the world to turn it around this year, which is why he remains so high in the rankings. However, if Bellinger does not find a way to reverse his current approach he will continue to slide down the tiers all year.

Dee Gordon is Dee Gordon. He is going to bat .300, steal 60 bases, and score between 90-100 runs.

Tier 4

Rhys Hoskins was out on the disabled list with a broken jaw after these rankings were finished and he should be dropped. The Phillies first baseman is not going to require surgery, but he should still be out for a while. No official timetable has been announced. Injuries are never a good thing, but it's possible that the young slugger could use some time off to clear his head. Hoskins was coming off an amazing rookie campaign that saw him put up 18 home runs in just 170 at-bats last year. 2018 has been a horse of a different color with the Hoskins hitting just .233 with a spike in his swinging strike rate and significant dip in hard contact. He did manage to hold onto a modest .182 ISO and decent .340 wOBA during his struggles, so maybe there is light at the end of the tunnel. Fantasy owners can hope that this time off gives Hoskins a chance to adjust and come back fresh and motivated.

Tommy Pham was a but of a polarizing player in the offseason when it came to projections and predictions. Could the out of nowhere Cardinal repeat his 2017 season? Or was it just a metric mirage? So far, so good for Pham who is putting up a .271/.372/.476 slah line with nine home runs and eight stolen bases. The St.Louis outfielder is holding a strong .367 wOBA and 134 wRC+ that helps solidify the legitimacy of the effort as well. The main issue for Pham this season has been injuries. He has missed games with a groin injury and almost cut his head open because his helmet was too tight. If he can avoid these types of mishaps he should be in for a strong season.

You can't go wrong with Khris Davis, he is about as consistent as they come. What you see is what you get, and what you get is 40 home runs. On the other hand. Justin Upton is a grab bag. Will he be good Justin or bad Justin? In roto leagues you don't have to worry as much through his streaky nature because at the end of the year he is going to put up his typical .260 25-20 home runs 85-95 RBI. In head-to- leagues is where Mr.Upton can cause some headaches. The veteran outfielder can either win you the week or be flat out useless. Still, the Angels power hitter is enough of a dynamic threat to remain entrenched near the top of the rankings.

Tier 5

Marcell Ozuna fell in the rankings after coming out with a disappointing start after his breakout 2017 campaign. Acquired from the Marlins in the off season, Ozuna was poised to pick up where he left off playing for the Cardinals. Instead he stumbled hard out of the gate and never really recovered, batting a disappointing .260/.305/.337 with a .284 wOBA and 78 wRC+. Ozuna's troubles have been compiled by off the field issues that have led to the outfielder being benched on more than on occasion for being late. All is not lost for the St. Louis slugger though, as he holds a solid 44.5% hard contact rate while also improving up his strikeout rate, chase rate, and swinging strike rate this season.

Andrew Benintendi joins Ozuna of those who fell down to this tier. However after a disappointing start, the Red Sox outfielder has caught fire and is looking like the guy everyone thought they drafted. Benintendi is batting .340 with six home runs and three stolen bases over the last 30 days, bringing his season slash line to .294/.376/.517 with a .378 wOBA. He is a stud dynasty plaer who should finish the season higher in the rankings as we go further into the summer.

Tier 6

Ronald Acuna was just as advertised before going down with an ACL sprain. The 20-year-old rookie was hitting .265/.326/.453 with seven doubles, five homers, 13 RBI, 19 runs and two steals in 29 games this season. The good news is that Acuna will likely be out only weeks instead on the months many feared. If you saw the play he was injured on, you would understand. These rankings were done prior to the DL stint, so downgrade him accordingly.

Mitch Haniger and Ender Inciarte are two of the highest climbers in the updated outfield rankings. Haniger should not have been a big surprise to those who followed him last season. The Seattle outfielder proved that he belonged in the major leagues in 2017 hitting .282/.352/.491 with 16 home runs. Haniger also proved to have solid plate discipline, carrying a 27.9% O-swing% (% of balls chased outside the zone). In 2018 he seems to have gotten even better, slashing .276/.361/.520 with a .373 wOBA, 11 home runs and three stolen bases. A well earned bump in the rankings.

Inciarte is an interesting player. He is consistent, yet always undervalued. Well we see you Ender, and we appreciate your efforts. The Braves' leadoff hitter has stolen 18 bases to lead the majors, hitting on top the one of the better hitting lineups in the National League. He is striking out a bit more than we would like, but he has proven to provide tremendous value in the speed department.

Tier 7

In case you did not get the memo, Shohei Ohtani is pretty good. We are just going to zero in on the imports hitting ability for the purposes of this article though. The Angels "rookie" is batting an a solid .291/.376/.533 with a .394 wOBA and six home runs through 103 at-bats. He loses a bit of value due to the fact that he doesn't play everyday, but what he lacks in quantity he makes up for n quality. Ohtani hits the ball hard almost every time, holding a 42.5% hard contact rate to just a 9.5% soft contact rate. The kid is legit, but you know that by now.

Michael Brantley has seen a resurrection of sorts in 2018. Everyday is the day we expect him to get injured, but here he stands. Brantley may not be the player he used to be, especially in the speed department, but he has contributed amazing value for an end of draft or possibly waiver wire add for fantasy owners. The Indians outfielder is hitting a fantastic .343/.383/.569 with nine home runs, a .405 wOBA and 156 wRC+. Honestly, he would be a lot higher in these rankings if he were anyone else. The injury bug follows Brantley around like a hungry puppy and it seems like just a matter of time.

*This would be the tier Juan Soto would likely fit in today, maybe even tier six.

Tier 8

A.J. Pollock fell pretty far in the rankings following a tremendous start due to an unfortunate thumb fracture that sent him to the disabled list. Pollock was one of the hottest hitters in baseball going down, but just like Michael Branltey, he is snake bit when it comes to injuries and setbacks and it's tough to see from such a talented player. He is currently due back from mid-to-late June.

Nomar Mazara is a hitting machine and one of the more underrated players in baseball. After a year in which Mazara hit 100 RBI, he came into the 2018 season as an afterthought in fantasy drafts. Even now, hitting .272/.343/.500 with a .360 wOBA and 12 home runs, Mazara remains an underappreciated fantasy asset. The Texas outfielder is just 23 years-old and should continue to hone is craft. Don't sleep on Nomar Mazara, he is a star, you just don't know it yet.

Tier 9

Advertising

Nick Markakis is having a bit of a resurgence this season, batting .332 with seven home runs for the Braves. The veteran is getting all sorts of help in the BABIP department (.344), but is nonetheless worthy of this huge bump in the rankings, Markakis has always been a professional hitter and has cut way down on his strikeout rate in 2018.

Corey Dickerson was cut by the Tampa Bay Rays this offseason. Corey Dickerson is batting ..308/.344/.492 with five home runs and three stolen bases for the Pirates. I repeat, Corey Dickerson was CUT by the Tampa Bay Rays this offseason. (insert rolling eyes .gif)

Tier 10 plus

Byron Buxton. We have seen this movie before. He is awful. We cut him. He comes back, We pick him up. He is awful. We cut him, He gets injured, Someone else picks him up. They cut him. Then he has a monster end to the season. It's just hard to see that happening again considering how lost he looks at the plate. That being said, he would be a good player to target once July rolls around. Until then, he will remain buried in the rankings.

Billy Hamilton may finally be on his last life. The speedy outfielder has been permanently planted in the nine hole in the Reds lineup. It looks like only a matter of time before he is seeing the bench or maybe the minor leagues.

Jay Bruce singed with the Mets this offseason with both of them knowing he had plantar fasciitis. This has bothered him all season long so far. Could we see a bounce back from Bruce and witness a wild hot streak? Sure. But this foot injury is not going anywhere and makes him a worrisome addition on a fantasy roster in 2018.

Matt Kemp was supposed to be released wasn't he? He sure didn't think so. The former MVP is back and looking great in the Dodgers outfield, batting .345/.372/.554 with a .393 wOBA and seven home runs. If he continues this trend going into June we may have to consider giving him a much larger jump in the rankings than we already have.

Domingo Santana was playing with fire in 2017, carrying a 30.9% HR/FB ratio. That is roughly double the league average. This season he has that rate down to a more sustainable 10.3%, which should go up actually. The Brewers outfielder has been picking it up lately but aside from his struggles at the plate, the additions of Lorenzo Cain and Christian Yelich in Milwaukee have put a playing time strain on Santana. He will need something to change to recapture his preseason hype.

Adam Eaton was the best hitter is baseball when he went down with an ankle injury in April. The Nationals center fielder was slashing ..343/.424/.655 with a .456 wOBA and 192 wRC+ to start the year. Unfortunately, injuries and Adam Eaton go together like peanut butter and jelly. Jelly being what his bones are made of. I kid,I kid. For what it's worth, Eaton is nearing his return and should be back in action sometime in early June. He could be an amazing asset if healthy and leading off for the Nationals, but how many at-bats will fantasy owners get out of him? We will have to see.