Nick Mariano's Top 150 Saves+Holds Rankings for Fantasy Baseball Relief Pitchers

2 years ago by Nick Mariano

Well, this article was going to run a bit later but we're shuffling things around because the people demand it. Or maybe just one person. Hi, Jordan, this one is for you! Saves+Holds reliever ranks can be overlooked or left stale from an early offseason article, but I'll be here at least once a month to bring my leaderboard for the season. Allow me, Nick Mariano, to do my namesake proud (my middle name isn't Rivera, sorry) and bring you the breakdown about fantasy baseball bullpens.

While the closer's role is important, an increasing number of managers are moving their best arm into a flexible role while shuffling who gets the ninth. Saves+Holds (or Solds, or SV+HLD) leagues help fantasy leagues reward the best arms regardless of the inning, though it still favors closers in a vacuum. Be sure to also check out our constantly updated fantasy baseball closers and saves depth charts.

Reminder: A hold is recorded when a relief pitcher enters with a lead of three runs or less, or with the tying run on deck, at the plate, or on base, and maintains that lead while recording at least one out. Read on and you'll see where I rank each player, what tier they're in, as well as a smattering of analysis for each of the 10 tiers. And here is the top 150 table in an exportable, able-to-be-copied Google sheet if you like. While I look for pitchers used in high-leverage situations, this is also about how good the arm is and how efficient their K/9 works for many of you.

Featured Promo: For this week only, take 50% off any full-season or yearly Premium Pass on the site! Just enter discount code THANKS when checking out. Thanks for being a reader, and Happy Holidays! Sign Up Now!

*Updated April 3*

2022 Saves+Holds Rankings - Mixed Leagues

Be sure to also bookmark our main 2022 fantasy baseball rankings dashboard. It's loaded up with tons of other great rankings including roto mixed leagues, H2H points leagues, AL/NL only leagues, prospect rankings and more.

Rank	Tier	Player	Team	Lg
1	1	Josh Hader	MIL	NL
2	1	Liam Hendriks	CWS	AL
3	2	Raisel Iglesias	LAA	AL
4	2	Ryan Pressly	HOU	AL
5	2	Edwin Diaz	NYM	NL
6	2	Giovanny Gallegos	STL	NL
7	2	Emmanuel Clase	CLE	AL
8	2	Devin Williams	MIL	NL
9	2	Craig Kimbrel	LAD	NL
10	2	Aroldis Chapman	NYY	AL
11	2	Blake Treinen	LAD	NL
12	3	Jordan Romano	TOR	AL
13	3	Taylor Rogers	MIN	AL
14	3	Kenley Jansen	ATL	NL
15	3	Paul Sewald	SEA	AL
16	3	Scott Barlow	KC	AL
17	3	David Bednar	PIT	NL
18	3	Lucas Sims	CIN	NL
19	4	Andrew Kittredge	TB	AL
20	4	Jonathan Loaisiga	NYY	AL
21	4	Diego Castillo	SEA	AL
22	4	Matt Barnes	BOS	AL
23	4	Hector Neris	HOU	AL
24	4	Jake McGee	SF	NL
25	4	William Smith	ATL	NL
26	4	Anthony Bender	MIA	NL
27	4	Corey Knebel	PHI	NL
28	4	Camilo Doval	SF	NL
29	4	Chad Green	NYY	AL
30	4	Mark Melancon	ARI	NL
31	5	Aaron Bummer	CWS	AL
32	5	Gregory Soto	DET	AL
33	5	Kendall Graveman	CWS	AL
34	5	Tyler Rogers	SF	NL
35	5	Ryan Tepera	LAA	AL
36	5	Art Warren	CIN	NL
37	5	A.J. Minter	ATL	NL
38	5	Matt Wisler	TB	AL
39	5	Daniel Hudson	LAD	NL
40	5	Garrett Whitlock	BOS	AL
41	6	Trevor May	NYM	NL
42	6	Tim Mayza	TOR	AL
43	6	Andrew Chafin	DET	AL
44	6	Clay Holmes	NYY	AL
45	6	Alex Vesia	LAD	NL
46	6	James Karinchak	CLE	AL
47	6	Tanner Rainey	WAS	NL
48	6	Brooks Raley	TB	AL
49	6	Phil Maton	HOU	AL
50	6	Lou Trivino	OAK	AL
51	6	Robert Suarez	SD	NL
52	6	Tyler Matzek	ATL	NL
53	6	Collin McHugh	ATL	NL
54	6	Josh Staumont	KC	AL
55	6	Jake Cousins	MIL	NL
56	6	Luis Garcia	SD	NL
57	6	Joe Barlow	TEX	AL
58	6	Jake Diekman	BOS	AL
59	6	Cole Sulser	BAL	AL
60	6	Dylan Floro	MIA	NL
61	6	Pierce Johnson	SD	NL
62	6	Alex Colome	COL	NL
63	7	Brusdar Graterol	LAD	NL
64	7	Brad Boxberger	MIL	NL
65	7	Jorge Alcala	MIN	AL
66	7	Tanner Scott	BAL	AL
67	7	Joe Kelly	CWS	AL
68	7	Austin Adams	SD	NL
69	7	Michael Fulmer	DET	AL
70	7	Richard Bleier	MIA	NL
71	7	Luis Cessa	CIN	NL
72	7	Drew Steckenrider	SEA	AL
73	7	Emilio Pagan	SD	NL
74	7	Mike Mayers	LAA	AL
75	7	Rowan Wick	CHC	NL
76	7	Amir Garrett	KC	AL
77	7	Jordan Hicks	STL	NL
78	7	Greg Holland	TEX	AL
79	7	Josh Taylor	BOS	AL
80	7	Nick Sandlin	CLE	AL
81	8	Aaron Loup	LAA	AL
82	8	Seth Lugo	NYM	NL
83	8	Ian Kennedy	ARI	NL
84	8	J.P. Feyereisen	TB	AL
85	8	Phil Bickford	LAD	NL
86	8	Tyler Duffey	MIN	AL
87	9	Dinelson Lamet	SD	NL
88	9	Jose Alvarado	PHI	NL
89	9	A.J. Puk	OAK	AL
90	9	Mychal Givens	CHC	NL
91	9	Robert Stephenson	COL	NL
92	9	Carlos Estevez	COL	NL
93	9	Joely Rodriguez	NYY	AL
94	9	Chris Stratton	PIT	NL
95	9	Ryne Stanek	HOU	AL
96	10	Daniel Bard	COL	NL
97	10	Chris Martin	CHC	NL
98	10	Adam Ottavino	NYM	NL
99	10	David Robertson	CHC	NL
100	10	Anthony Bass	MIA	NL
101	10	Brad Hand	PHI	NL
102	10	Yimi Garcia	TOR	AL
103	10	Genesis Cabrera	STL	NL
104	10	Nick Wittgren	STL	NL
105	10	Trevor Richards	TOR	AL
106	10	Kyle Finnegan	WAS	NL
107	10	Sam Howard	PIT	NL
108	10	Spencer Patton	TEX	AL
109	10	Connor Brogdon	PHI	NL
110	10	Julian Merryweather	TOR	AL
111	10	Anthony Gose	CLE	AL
112	10	Hirokazu Sawamura	BOS	AL
113	10	Deolis Guerra	OAK	AL
114	10	Caleb Smith	ARI	NL
115	10	Scott Effross	CHC	NL
116	10	Sergio Romo	SEA	AL
117	10	Ryan Brasier	BOS	AL
118	10	JT Chargois	TB	AL
119	10	Brent Suter	MIL	NL
120	10	Domingo Acevedo	OAK	AL
121	10	Wandy Peralta	NYY	AL
122	10	Steve Cishek	WAS	NL
123	10	Jake Brentz	KC	AL
124	10	Dylan Coleman	KC	AL
125	10	Richard Rodriguez	FA	--
126	10	Anthony Misiewicz	SEA	AL
127	10	Ryan Helsley	STL	NL
128	10	Victor Gonzalez	LAD	NL
129	10	Sean Doolittle	WAS	NL
130	10	Adam Cimber	TOR	AL
131	10	Jeurys Familia	PHI	NL
132	10	Tim Hill	SD	NL
133	10	Caleb Thielbar	MIN	AL
134	10	Yusmeiro Petit	FA	--
135	10	Miguel Castro	NYM	NL
136	INJ	Drew Pomeranz	SD	NL
137	INJ	Ken Giles	SEA	AL
138	INJ	Nick Anderson	TB	AL
139	INJ	Kirby Yates	ATL	NL
140	INJ	Jose Leclerc	TEX	AL
141	INJ	Colin Poche	TB	AL
142	INJ	Tommy Kahnle	LAD	NL
143	INJ	Pete Fairbanks	TB	AL
144	INJ	Andres Munoz	SEA	AL
145	INJ	Alex Reyes	STL	NL
146	INJ	Seranthony Dominguez	PHI	NL
147	INJ	Caleb Ferguson	LAD	NL
148	INJ	Brad Wieck	CHC	NL
149	INJ	Jonathan Hernandez	TEX	AL
150	INJ	Trevor Rosenthal	FA	--

Saves+Holds Tiered Rankings Analysis

Tier One

Not much needs explaining here, as Hader and Hendriks are both masterclass closers with monstrous strikeout rates and strong control. While each of them has another elite reliever behind them, both the Brewers and White Sox have shown a steadfast commitment to both Hader and Hendriks, respectively. Draft with confidence, strut with pride. Maybe just cover the kiddies’ ears when Hendriks is pitching, though.

Tier Two

While saves remain more predictable than holds, you can’t help but bring in the aforementioned elite relievers behind Hader and Hendriks with Devin Williams and Craig Kimbrel. Update: Kimbrel was indeed traded as we hoped for, and to the Dodgers no less! Great for him, as he seems to require the adrenaline of the ninth inning. We'll see how it goes. But Treinen is still a strong play as LAD's fireman. As for Williams, the airbender encountered turbulence in 2021 but from July 1 on, Williams posted a 38/8 K/BB with a 1.52 ERA (1.65 FIP) alongside three wins, three saves, and 10 holds in 23 ⅔ IP of work. That’ll play.

Tier Three

In SV-only leagues, you start sweating around this point. Will they, won’t they? That's the beauty of SV+HLD formats, because these are all still damn good pitchers and you should feel strong in drafting them. Admittedly, it begins to become more about the volume rather than the microscopic ratios or electrifying strikeouts at this juncture, but for the most part, you are still getting healthy K’s and ratios with your SV+HLD volume.

As of late March, Lucas Sims is currently healthy but behind schedule due to earlier injuries delaying his spring training routine. If he were still hurt then I’d dock him further down towards the 30’s, but his upside is immense when healthy. In case you’ve forgotten, he led all relievers with a 42% K-BB rate from August 1 on last season.

Tier Four

Now the murky bullpen pictures start to creep in, but we are prepared to extract all sorts of value from the 7th and 8th innings. Andrew Kittredge never panned out as a starter but has found all sorts of life as a fastball-slider RP that brought his walk rate down to a career-best 5.3% last season. The Rays will use him all over the place and those late-inning leverage spots yielded nine wins and 15 SV+HLD in 71 ⅔ IP. He and Chad Green are capable of 70-80 frames on command with wins, saves, holds, whatever you need.

Tier Five

This is where the fun begins. It is around this point in drafts where you can tell who hasn’t played the format before. I’d like to lean this column towards the relievers who I don’t feel get enough shine in other articles. As a result, one of the better mid-tier targets to chat up is Daniel Hudson.

Did you know he had a beautiful 2.65 SIERA underneath the 3.31 ERA last year? A career-high 35.7% strikeout rate, mixed with his best walk rate in seven years at 7.6%, will do that. He doesn’t need to retain all of those gains for this to be profitable, but it sure would be snazzy. His heater averaged 97 mph last year while his slider zipped up a few ticks to 88 mph, which settles in nicely with Dave Roberts’ plan to use all of his back-end pieces interchangeably in the late frames behind Kimbrel, if Kimbrel can hold on.

*I’m including Garrett Whitlock here in case he doesn’t win a rotation spot, even though I kind of completely expect him to.

Tier Six

Here you’ll find some southpaws who make their way into the conversation in Alex Vesia, Josh Taylor, and Andrew Chafin. It may hold them back from closing consideration, but we’ve unshackled ourselves from that limitation. Free your mind and accept us left-handers into your world.

And while everyone knows the Yankees’ trio of Chapman-Loaisiga-Green, we have to stump for Clay Holmes. The Yanks saw something in Holmes despite a 4.93 ERA, 1.43 WHIP and 13.2% walk rate in his fourth year with Pittsburgh. They told him to attack the zone more with his power sinker and his first-strike rate went up four percentage points, his walk rate as a Yankee was only 3.9% over 28 innings! And he didn’t lose whiffs from it, as his K% shot up from 23.3% with PIT to 33% with NYY. I see no reason for him to shed most of these gains.

Tier Seven

Let’s tackle a few more reclamation/comeback stories, shall we? Ken Giles is hitting 95 mph and should be ready for spring action shortly. I’d expect him to be a big part of Seattle’s late-inning committee and recover his above-average whiffs in kind. Update: Giles is shut down with a finger injury, so I've bumped Diego Castillo and Drew Steckenrider up a tad. I’m less sure of Amir Garrett due to his lofty walk rates, but Kauffman Stadium can help with the home run issues compared to Great American Ballpark. Your WHIP may suffer, but hopefully, a high-threes ERA and sizeable strikeouts fall in line as KC’s premier lefty.

Also, I cannot miss a chance to promote Jorge Alcala’s top-tier slider and his posting a 27/3 K/BB with a 1.90 ERA (1.94 FIP) in his final 21 games of 2021.

Tier Eight

So the excitement is starting to wear down and you are starting to decide between SVHLD volume and solid ratios/whiffs. Towards the end of 2021, Seth Lugo said he prefers being a multi-inning fireman after a couple of seasons where injuries have curtailed his usage. If we get back to the 2018-19 Lugo who was pushing 80-plus frames with sub-3.00 ERAs and plenty of holds in the process then we’re cooking. Still only 32 years old, look for Lugo to serve a key role on a hungry Mets squad.

Or just double dip with the frighteningly-deep Braves bullpen through Tyler Matzek. You can run into a problem with these guys all cannibalizing each other for opportunities ahead of Kenley Jansen, but Atlanta is going to win many a ballgame. Don’t feel like stacking is going to bite you in this scenario.

Tier Nine

The intrigue grows the deeper we go, with two names standing out to me in particular. You may still think of A.J. Puk and Dinelson Lamet as starters, but let us recalibrate that. Both Oakland and San Diego are trying to keep them healthy in the bullpen, as the initial 2022 plans mirror the 2021 approach.

While Lamet has at least had some stretches with sustained health, he was bit by the dreaded right forearm tightness last June and only mustered a 19/11 K/BB ratio with a 6.39 ERA (5.06 FIP) in 12.2 IP of relief in September/October upon returning. It wasn’t pretty. But if he can ramp that fastball back up towards 97-98 mph and locate his devastating slider out of the ‘pen, then SD may have a true Weapon X on their hands again. Meanwhile, Puk is stretching out for a chance at a rotation spot but I’m skeptical enough where a later flier here on his being a relief ace instead is worthwhile.

Tier 10+

Let the “if” parade commence. If Julian Merryweather can stay healthy, if Adam Ottavino can consistently locate his breaking pitches, if Drew Pomeranz comes back to vintage form, you get the picture. Another layer of “if” lies in your IL stash capabilities. I try to avoid actively-hurt arms because other injuries will find you, but if you can hold Nick Anderson, Kirby Yates, and Jose Leclerc then you may be paid off handsomely down the stretch. Here's hoping Tommy Kahnle's changeup is still an assassin.

Download Our Free News & Alerts Mobile App

Like what you see? Download our updated fantasy baseball app for iPhone and Android with 24x7 player news, injury alerts, sleepers, prospects & more. All free!